We Will Fall Together

I was paddling across the lake, pleasantly high, not overbearingly stoned, trying to take a good picture of my shoes up on my kayak against the horizon, when Captain Johnny threw me a rope and demanded that I climb onto his pontoon boat. He said he had something he wanted to show me. I could see a cooler full of beer behind him, so it seemed like as good an idea as any. I tied the rope into the netting of my kayak and pulled myself up to the boat and climbed on. My kayak floated behind us.

Aboard the boat were CJ, his wife Suzy, and the kid who lived next door to them, Taud. Taud, pronounced however you want, spent all his free time every summer at CJ’s house banging around on old riding-mower engines. If they could get one working again, CJ would sell it on Facebook Marketplace. He made a killing, but the HOA hated all the giant mowers in his driveway and the fact that he was running a business out of his home.

Captain Johnny had made everyone start calling him that when he bought his first boat with mower money. As far as I knew, only Suzy and their kids that don’t talk to him anymore knew CJ’s real name. As for Suzy, she was just a nice lady. I think she was just kind of sad that her husband was crazy, but I don’t want to assume.

CJ handed me a beer. “That cuckold Thomas is at it again,” he said conspiratorially. I nodded. He patted at my shirt, knocking away a dragonfly that had clung to my shoulder. “No free rides,” he shouted at the dragonfly. He looked at me and laughed. “I’m always saying that.” He leaned in closer. “I’ve got something for him, though—Thomas, I mean.” I realized then that Taud had been tearing back and forth across the little boat in a panic. He looked under each bench, opened each cooler, slammed the tiny cabinet by the steering mount.

“I can’t find it, Captain,” Taud shouted.

“Because,” Suzy said, “I threw it out.” She was leaning back with her arms draped over the side of the boat.

“I know you did,” said CJ. “So I made another.”

“Another what?” I asked. I’d already drained half the beer he’d given me.

He answered my question with a question. “Are you familiar with the idea of a potato gun?” he asked.

“Yeah.”

“Oh, then yeah. A potato gun.”

“I’m telling you, I threw it out,” Suzy said. “Both of them.” She ashed her cigarette into the water. She was wearing a big dress covered in sunflowers under her life jacket. It looked like a shower curtain. I could smell her smoke on the breeze mingling with the fishy freshwater smell of decay you get on a big lake near the end of summer.

“Both of them? How could you?”

“You were going to hurt yourself.”

“I was going to hurt Thomas,” CJ clarified. He stood kind of hunched over, both shoulders forward, elbows out, hands rolled into fists at the bottom of his gut.

Suzy was still looking out over the lake, toward their house by the dock. The lawnmower graveyard glinted in the sunlight like a field of shiny green beetle shells. “Maybe,” she said.

“Who’s Thomas?” I asked. I thought I kept a pretty good tally of everyone who lived around the lake, but I was a little high and a little drunk, so maybe I forgot someone. It was mostly retirees. I lived about forty-five minutes down the road, but I spent every day in the water since getting laid off six months before.

Suzy stood up. “Tommy,” she said. She reached into one of the coolers and pulled out a Twisted Tea. “Tugboat Tommy.”

CJ stomped his foot. “Do not call him that, like he’s some kind of child and not a grown man responsible for his own actions.”

“Ah,” I said, “Ah-ha.” I helped myself to another beer.

TT and CJ were mortal enemies. I’d just never heard anyone go full-government-name on Tugboat Tommy before. Tommy was a nice enough guy who spent his retirement floating around on his pontoon with his wife and sometimes their two grandkids. As for CJ’s issue, well, TT was the uncontested president of the HOA. I’d heard he was a stickler for the rules, but I never had a problem with him. One time, he’d motored past me while I was smoking a joint in my kayak. I hid it behind my back and held the smoke in my mouth. He pointed and laughed and pretended he was smoking too with his fingers and then yelled “Puff puff! Puff puff!” before cackling some more. So I figured we were cool. Besides, how uptight can a guy named Tugboat Tommy really be?

“Are you done with that?” CJ asked me, pointing at the empty can I’d set down.

“Yeah,” I said, “Why?” But instead of answering, he scooped up the can and started cutting the top off with a pocketknife. He grabbed an empty can by Suzy’s foot and started doing the same thing.

“What in God’s name are you doing?” Suzy asked.

“Improvising,” CJ said. “That bastard’s due to come back around this side of the turtle island any minute now.”

“Hey,” Taud whispered to me.

“What’s up?”

“Can I hit your vape?”

“What?” I asked.

“Can I hit your vape?” he said, louder.

“How old are you?”

“Eighteen.”

I stared at him.

“Sixteen,” Taud mumbled.

“What?”

“I’m sixteen.”

“No, you can’t hit my vape, you little rat,” I said. He scurried to the other side of the boat and started digging around under the seats and in the glovebox again. I looked over to CJ and saw he was now four cans deep into what was starting to look like a beer can potato gun. He was wrapping them together with gauze and medical tape from the first aid kit, ripping the labels off the cans and throwing scraps everywhere along the boat as he went.

“Honey, sweety,” Suzy said.

“Will you relax?” CJ said. “It’s going to be funny. It’s a prank.”

“Sweety, honey,” Suzy said. But he was back at it with the knife. As he worked, he made a pile of discarded paper and tape and gauze underneath one of the wooden benches. I wondered where the potatoes were. Was there a sack of potatoes in one of these beer coolers? Taud nudged me off the chest-bench I was sitting on to lift it open and check inside. He pulled something not-potato-shaped out and put it under his shirt.

“What do you have?” I asked. But he didn’t answer, and I didn’t really care. Then the boat rocked from the wake of Tommy’s boat. He had one of those nice double-decker pontoons where you could lay out on top of the awning and throw rocks at birds or the person steering.

Tugboat Tommy cut his engine and his wife stood up and waved with both hands, sloshing a canned margarita onto her bikini. “Hey there Suzy!” she called out. She was incredibly tan from laying on the top of the boat all day, every day. Her hair was grey and ran all the way down her back. She was standing by the steering rig next to Tugboat Tommy.

“Howdy, Dar,” Suzy said, tipping a Twisted Tea toward her in salute.

“We’ve been celebrating,” Tommy said. He put his arm around his wife.

“Is that so?” CJ asked. Taud stood beside him, glaring ahead with both hands in his pockets. He looked like a police K9 waiting for a command. Captain Johnny was hunched over, hiding what he was fidgeting with from view. It would have looked less suspicious if they’d just seen him messing with the cans.

“It’s our anniversary!” Darlene said, swinging her arms in the air as she said it, breaking free of Tugboat Tommy’s arm around her and almost going overboard before catching the railing. The water was normally still, but our boats were rocking from the other pontoons pulling up on us.

They were circling the water like sharks.

“Still babysitting, though,” Tugboat Tommy said, nodding up with his chin. Their grandkids, Aurora and Brexit, a twin girl and boy, were up top throwing rocks at birds.

“Don’t call it that,” Darlene said. “You make it sound like a chore. They’re celebrating, too.”

“How old are the little rugrats now?” Suzy asked.

“Eight,” Tommy said proudly.

Brixadi beamed Tommy in the back of the head with a rock. “Eight and a half,” he corrected.

“How do they have rocks up there?” I asked. I’m not sure if they thought it was rhetorical or if they just didn’t think I was worth answering, but no one answered me. I guess they filled their pockets before getting on the boat.

I saw Captain Johnny reach into Suzy’s purse and pull out a can of hair spray. He sprayed it into the tube of cans.

There were four or five other boats floating nearby; they were in earshot, but not close enough for a convenient conversation. They had all cut their engines.

It’s worth mentioning here that CJ and TT had had some prolific screaming matches before this. Sometimes on the lake, sometimes in the middle of the road, sometimes at the local lobster joint that had open mic nights on Thursdays. Tugboat Tommy road around on a little golf cart enforcing the HOA rules and would pull up to Captain Johnny’s driveway while he’d be playing the radio too loud and working on mowers. On the lake, they’d pass each other’s boats and start screaming at each other so loudly you could hear it from the other side of the water. I’d only ever seen them from afar, but I always saw the crowd of boats build up around them. Retired folks are always looking for a show, I guess. This was the first time I’d been this close.

“Sounds like we’ve got a lot to celebrate today, then,” Captain Johnny said. He looked like he’d just smelled something awful. “Maybe I should POP some champagne?” He whipped the stack of cans up level with Tugboat Tommy. He held a lighter to the side of one of the cans. There was a WOOSH sound as a giant flash erupted from CJ’s hands and all of the gauze and tape holding his contraption together caught on fire and the cans fell apart and dropped into the water.

“Fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck,” chanted CJ, whose hands were on fire. He jumped around patting them on his pants before sticking them into a cooler full of ice. A potato rolled across the deck of the pontoon and stopped at my foot. It was one of the little red ones. Probably the perfect size for a beer can. I wondered where Taud’s parents were and whether they cared that he spent all day with an insane old man. Suzy, Tommy, and Darlene all stared, mouths wide open. Tommy seemed especially horrified. The twins grinned and clapped, enraptured by the fire. Taud stood like a Buckingham Palace guard. I heard someone in one of the surrounding boats yell Holy Shit!

“You alright, CJ?” I asked.

“Again!” Breton shouted.

“Do it again!” Arugula demanded.

CJ stood up, wiping his palms dry on his pants. He readjusted his captain hat, then his life jacket. He took a deep breath.

“I’m guessing that’s not the desired performance of that doohickey?” Tugboat Tommy asked.

“Fuck you, Thomas.”

“Do those tractors you build backfire in the same fashion?”

“They’re not tractors, asshole!” Taud shouted, any air of calm or cool he’d manufactured completely dissipating. “They’re mowers! Mowers!”

“I’ll handle him, Taud,” CJ said, looking over his shoulder to meet Taud’s eyes. “Don’t lower yourself to this pond scum. You’re a good boy, now.” Captain Johnny looked to Tommy. “My mowers are perfect. But I’m sure that means nothing to some used up old prune who doesn’t even mow his own lawn.”

“No one mows their own lawn!” Tommy shouted. “We have a contract with a landscaping company! Everyone’s yard is mowed as part of your HOA dues!”

“Blow it out your ass,” CJ shouted back.

Suzy stood up, spiked her half full Twisted Tea on the deck of the boat and sprayed booze everywhere. My ankles were splashed and I could feel my leg hairs sticking together. “Enough!” she shouted.

“Yeah! Get your oaf of a husband under control!” Darlene screamed.

“Excuse me?” said Suzy.

“Do another firework!” Austerity shouted.

“More fire!” squealed Brevity. They were jumping up and down on the top level of the boat in tandem and causing it to rock.

“You heard me,” Darlene said.

“How dare you speak about my husband like that, you lush,” Suzy shouted.

“Lush? Lush? Me? Baby, are you going to let this bitch talk to me like that?”

“If the shoe fits,” CJ shouted.

“Fuck you,” Tugboat Tommy said. He looked to Suzy. “Fuck you too,” he shouted. He spat in the water. “You people are filth.”

“Don’t you dare speak to my wife like that,” Captain Johnny blasted back. “I’ll kill you, you rotten, cobweb-cocked bastard. Do you let the boys who mow your lawn fuck your wife too, Thomas?”

At that, Thomas ripped his life jacket off and threw it on the ground. He ripped open his striped vest, buttons flying everywhere, then took off his undershirt too. His chest was gray and hairy. “I’ve had enough of you!” he shouted. He took off one of his Sperry shoes and launched it at CJ’s head, but he ducked and it flew into the water. “Your house is a blight on the HOA. Your boat is a floating piece of fish shit!”

“Yeah!” Darlene shouted. “Fuck you!” She threw her can and it hit me in the head. The premade margarita drink dripped down my face and I licked my lips and it tasted truly, horribly awful.

“More! Fire! More! Fire!” Brioche and Auricle chanted as each went up and down, up and down. One leaned in and started whispering to the other. They both stopped jumping and sauntered down the ladder before looking for something.

Captain Johnny threw his hat on the deck. “Fuck you, Thomas,” he howled. “Fuck you, fuck you, fuck you!”

I looked around us in the water. People were on their boats with their phones out taking pictures, eating snacks. My buzz was wearing off. I’d always wanted a closer look at one of these arguments, but I never wanted to be this close—this observed.

“Hey!” Taud yelled. The two old men stopped ripping off their clothes and screaming at each other. Taud stared down Tugboat Tommy. “Are you going to make it so me and the Captain can’t work on lawnmowers anymore?”

“Of course I am,” spat Tommy.

Taud reached into his waistband and pulled out a flare gun and pointed it directly at Tugboat Tommy.

“Whoa, shit, kid,” CJ said.

“Are you fucking kidding me?” Tommy screamed. The people surrounding us in their boats were losing their minds. I wondered if any of the crowd were young enough to be live streaming us. I could see Ginger Solezak in the crowd with her phone up, so we’d at least be ending up in a multi-paragraph long Facebook rant. And Harold, who ran the neighborhood email group I’d managed to get myself added to by pretending to be someone’s nephew, was standing at the end of his boat with his hands on his hips. His wife Mary was shaking her head in disbelief.

Then I noticed it.

“Hey!” I shouted, “Hey! Everyone! Hey!” I finally had their attention. I pointed to Auscultation. She was also holding a flare gun and pointing it at CJ.

“Fire!” Breviary shouted.

I don’t know who shot first, but the flare shot at us landed in the pile of gauze and tape under the bench that CJ had made while working on the failed potato gun. It all went up at once, then the bench. CJ and Taud were panicking to put it out. CJ tried to dump a cooler onto it, but he tripped over the hairspray, kicking it into the fire. It exploded immediately. When I looked over at Tugboat Tommy’s boat, I could tell that Taud’s flare had landed somewhere bad too. The top deck was almost completely engulfed already. The twins were holding hands and dancing frantically, their eyes rolled back and glazed over.

“Fuck you, Thomas!” CJ shouted.

“Fuck you harder, you fucking idiot! Look what you’ve done!”

“What I’ve done? Look at your little demon spawn, hailing the fire they were born from.”

“I’m going to fucking kill you! How dare you!”

“Help!” Darlene shouted. “Help! Help!” but none of the other boaters did anything. They were all just laughing and shouting and taking pictures. Suzy lit a cigarette off the flames and leaned over the side of the boat, quietly looking toward her house with all the mowers in the yard. Smoke trailed lazily from her lips and joined the plume rising from both pontoons.

“Just jump in the water! What the fuck is wrong with you people?” screamed one of the voyeurs, a brown-haired woman in her twenties on a rental boat. I made eye contact and she looked at me with disgust, like a waiter had just brought her a plate full of bugs. I grabbed CJ’s pocketknife off the table next to some tops of cans he’d cut off. I dove into the water and swam to my kayak and used his knife to cut the rope. I could smell smoke and burning plastic and diesel. I started paddling away toward the sunset, which was beautiful and orange behind all the smoke, and I tried to think of things I could add to my resume. I could still hear them shouting almost an entire mile away toward where I’d parked my car.

“Fuck you, Thomas! I hope you burn to death!”

“You first, Clarence, you useless old fuck!”

Clarence?


Max Zell is a technical writer and copyeditor out of Pittsburgh, PA. He lives with his girlfriend Kate and their cats Salmon and Bagel. He’s also an organizer for https://WritersInPittsburgh.org. When he’s not writing funky little stories, you can catch him on one of Pittsburgh’s three rivers in one of his three kayaks. You can also find him on Bluesky as @MaxZell.Bsky.Social.

Leave a Reply